Rechecking Formula for Critical Damage

If you believe with absolute confidence that the data you have is correct, please provide your data you have to claim that the information is incorrect. Also note that there is a lot of extra variance in stats, equipment, totems, bonus damage, crit dmg, etc that need to be factored in. Make sure that you have all possible external variables controlled.

I will try to upload the data as soon as I can. I have it on paper than in an excel spreadsheet.

I am aware there can be a lot of variance in stats, which is why I was asking help to verify. Someone else testing and reaching same conclusion would be a better proof than data check cause we can't really 'verify' my data as I can only state my stats and others have to believe it. (Unless many screenshots of stat window, Homestead, renown etc). Perhaps I can simplify things by testing again on an alt....

I will still upload mine incase anyone wants to see.

I tested again on an alt, with relatively no skills leveled, so their balance is 50% with rF Critical Hit. The data file is an excel file, and am unable to upload it here (I couldn't figure how to). Damage numbers being smaller it was easier to see that sometimes, foxes use defense skill without the skill icon and that causes reduced crit hits. I plotted the damage distribution as well from 136 damage points, so I can confirm there was enough damage rolls from lower end, due to low balance. The Crit Damage formula seems consistent even at minimum critical hits.

I am unsure if defense skill from foxes is only issue in my old test, I couldn't find what rank Brown foxes have for defense skill. But from the test on alt, it seems it is rF cause reduction seemed ~20?

Thanks for the help with solving my confusion!

So I think this discussion can be closed ^^