Carnivorous Fish

I just fished up a carnivorous fish from my ice fishing hole (homestead) Physis isn't one of the places listed as being able to get the carnivorous fish, so I'm thinking that it's a possible option with the candy bait. Does location matter when fishing with candy bait? Should carnivorous fish be added to the candy bait fish list, or should Physis be added to the carnivorous fish list?

Yeah, I caught one too, but I never checked the fishing list.

For now, I say add it to the homestead list. If anyone fishes up one in a physis homestead after the event with normal bait and remembers this, they can remove it from the homestead event list and add it to the physis one.