Mabinogi World Wiki is brought to you by Coty C., 808idiotz, our other patrons, and contributors like you!!
Keep this wiki going by contributing to our Patreon!

G16S2 Anti-Bot

G16S2 Anti-Bot

Did they actually put in the anti-bot thing for Dunbartion/Cobh/Belvast? Because I got zip from trading in Shark Fins and Neid Scales (from Cobh) at the Commonwealth of Belvast, despite saying I get a whole bunch of profit.

Infodude57523:14, 2 July 2012

I traded Dark Swords from Belvast to Dunbarton and I actually got rewarded o-o

Someone else help me clarify this?

Infodude57514:40, 5 July 2012
 

Did you get gold?

Zugon (Talk | contribs)14:55, 5 July 2012
 

EXP, Gold, Merchant Rating, whats not to get?

Infodude57515:01, 5 July 2012
 

Probably wasn't implemented.

Zugon (Talk | contribs)15:13, 5 July 2012
 
 
 
Because I got zip from trading in Shark Fins and Neid Scales (from Cobh) at the Commonwealth of Belvast, despite saying I get a whole bunch of profit.
 

 

As in it would say "+XX" when I purchased it, then it said "Ducat XX" and "EXP 0" when I traded it.

Infodude57515:15, 5 July 2012
 

I misread you. I did a trade myself, and only got back what I spent when it said that there was profit. Think it's safe to say it's implemented. Also, apologies for my mistake.

Zugon (Talk | contribs)15:29, 5 July 2012
 

Mistakes happen, don't get worked over it dude.

Infodude57516:03, 5 July 2012
 

Incubus Suits from Dunbarton to Belvast, zip. And apparently it showed an absurd ^900...

Shall we test with every item they have in stock?

Infodude57522:03, 5 July 2012
 

Spider Gloves from Dunbarton to Cobh and Oysters from Cobh to Dunbartion, ^1, got profit.

Is it only the first two items that get stuff while the rest get zip?

Infodude57509:58, 15 July 2012
 

I tried Spider Gloves from Dunbarton to Cobh myself before, and didn't get anything.

Zugon (Talk | contribs)19:22, 15 July 2012
 

Did it say vX?

Infodude57519:30, 15 July 2012
 

Pretty sure it said ^1, but I tried again and got something.

Zugon (Talk | contribs)19:36, 15 July 2012
 

Weird, I took cobh Jellyfish to the smuggler, it was before he left and I traded it in, I gained the exact amount of ducats it's worth, I gained exp for the trip, and lost commerce exp cuz it was my 2nd daily trade good that day...

The oddest part was that i got no ducat for it... When it's suppose to be profitable... 110 Jellyfish on a wagon where the smuggler is suppose to give me 81 profit for each one...

The smuggler went to silab cuilin so that's near tailteann...

Dra6o0n (talk)14:06, 22 August 2012
 

What does the smuggler have to do with this?

Infodude575 (talk)16:29, 23 August 2012
 

I think he's saying they applied the anti-bot system to the daily good item because he traded in a daily good item to Byrun twice (different game days) and yielded no profit the second time.

--Aramet (Talk)16:41, 23 August 2012
 

O-o...

That's totally wtf. Smugglers aren't easy to find and to get to...

Infodude575 (talk)16:43, 23 August 2012
 

I would actually require more testing to be sure.

Aubog007 (talk)17:47, 23 August 2012
 

That or the smuggler's rate can be killed by many players spamming it, so I dunno if it's a good idea to rely on smuggler all the time when people seemingly kill the rate the same way they kill off popular routes...

Dra6o0n (talk)12:22, 24 August 2012
 

Yeah I think the daily trade good is literally only good once, it does not give you ducats the 2nd time and it penalizes you by lowering your commerce exp for that town...

No idea if this is a bug because if it's your second daily trade good, then shouldn't it count like a 'normal' goods and give you increased price for it like any other goods sold to smuggler?

If you gain x profit from the 1st one, you will get the x profit in exact same value as the item you bought for...

So if you bought 100 items for 1000 ducats each, then you will make the same 'profit' but in actuality it's equal to your spending... Thus ducats returned.

Dra6o0n (talk)15:22, 27 August 2012
 

Uh... hello?

 
 
It works only once, though, as trading the Daily Trade Good more than once will decrease your Merchant Rating after the first trade.
 

 

 

Yes but consider this: I traded a daily trade good once, got the rewards it gives. Then if it only works once, shouldn't it be considered a 'normal' trade on the 2nd try then and still give you profit? That's the thing that should be fixed, it should give you a profit AND decrease your rating if you keep using the smuggler.

Dra6o0n (talk)14:00, 28 August 2012

Oh, I was responding to the "penalizes you by lowering your commerce exp for that town" part.

 

It gives you a profit. It just doesn't show it as profit. It shows it as a massive lump sum. the + whatever shows as BONUS profit and exp.

Aubog007 (talk)04:46, 29 August 2012
 

Well that's the thing, i brought jellyfish to the smuggler on the 2nd time, and it shows no changes, it just gave me my ducats back while giving me exp for the trip and deducting my commerce exp by 22k... Meaning I should have profited about 15k?

Basically it looks like this:

Ducat: [same amount]

Exp: [No changes] <- But It did show the exp got notification

Dra6o0n (talk)21:07, 31 August 2012