...

Shall we have a debate now, due to the revisions?

Well he travels along with you. I don't believe he's an NPC that actually sells stuff and etc. He always makes remarks about how bumpy the carts are and etc.

Not to mention the G15 posters show an imp traveling with the players.

How does that prove that they are different?

Explain to me how they are the same. Also NPC portraits are different for each town. Yet the imp has the same portrait when trading with you.

Also the NPC is called Trade Mercantile Imp. Isn't it?

Ah, you just reminded me of another thing. In another wiki talk page we decided to have one page for all of the Imps, Goblins, and Ogres in Trade Posts (not including the citizens of Belvast). He IS the Tir Chonaill Trade Post Imp. Even if he wasn't, he still belongs on this list. And you need to prove they're different, not demand proof that they're the same because until you find better counterargumental proof, Infodude's point still stands true.

Different portraits, Different names. Only thing that says he is what he is at the end conversation. But the prefix for his name is different.

I'm going to check cobh. If it says Trade Assistant Imp as the NPC name. Ill back down. That's my resounding argument.

Yea. My argument stands.

As I said, he has the same portrait as Tir Chonaill's imp because he is him! And that's good enough proof as it is. (Also you can edit these posts, you know.)

Actually that's not really proof.
Both Carasek and Karis have the same NPC image and the same BGM, but have different lines.
By the way... there's also an Imp in the Erinn Martial Arts Tournament that also uses the same NPC Portrait as the Tir Chonaill's Imp and the Trade Assistant Imp.

Dislike liquid threading immensely. Too much hassle to edit cause my browser doesnt load scripts properly. If you wanna edit it fine. But it's not the same "NPC"

Proof!

And i just got a quote saying the trade assistant imp wishes to run his own shop one day.

NA Nexon? Good at translating? really. Now you tell me.

“	I'm going to check cobh. If it says Trade Assistant Imp as the NPC name. Ill back down. That's my resounding argument.	„

Yes. I went and held ALT over the name. Not actually talked to them. /usingchromenow. Anyways ending a conversation and showing the name of the character was never a method to figure out if they are the same.

Which they are not.

That is irrelevant, each Trade Post NPC has a different name. (Plus you don't need to hold alt to see NPC names.)

And? So the imp in tir decides to follow you everywhere and leave his shop running and yet spews out that he wants to run a shop someday in his dialogue.

Ok.

Then again last time i said Shadow spirit didn't reduce protection... Major revision war happened.

• sigh*

I have a feeling this page is going to be locked eventually.

It's fine. I'm done. Page should be split into two pages.

That's my opinion.

...I'm pretty sure they are not the same (which was the original intention of this page btw)...I mean what kind of imp leaves shop and travels with you. I mean unless there's like a ton of imps (which is my guess) and one travels with you while the main imp at the trading post stays and he sends you a travel guide....but my head hurts after looking at the revisions @@;;

basically...there are multiple trade assistant imps, but this page when i created it, I had the assistant imp that travels with you in mind. ..not the ones at the trading post :x

There's no evidence that they're the same, but there's also zero evidence that they are different.

Since this is the case, it's better to shove the data onto one page rather than making two separate pages.