Mabinogi World Wiki is brought to you by Coty C., 808idiotz, our other patrons, and contributors like you!!
Keep this wiki going by contributing to our Patreon!

Edit

Fragment of a discussion from Talk:Macha

Okay there are a lot of things wrong in your post, and not to be rude but they are and I'm going to go over them one by one.

  • Morrighan
    • Unrealistic is an opinion.
    • They specifically said they made copies of statues identical to the real statue of her and placed them around Erinn in that book.
      • As an extension to this, they only destroyed SOME of the Goddess Statues, there's no evidence any were the real ones or how many were really destroyed.
    • It being called a legend is irrelevant, there can be true legends and there is nothing to suggest that book is or is not true.
    • "Given that she is not the statue itself" is conjecture.
    • Taking the book purely as poetic would be an assumption.
    • "accurate to conclude the statues are an extension of her power like conduits, nothing more." is baseless.
    • This isn't related to your post but I may also like to add that we don't ever actually see Morrighan in Erinn until G16, every other instance of her has been in Another World, Her Altar Room (don't say that is or is not anywhere because there is no proof), in the Shadow Realm, in Falias, in the Soul Stream, or in Avon. None of those places are in Erinn and the only time we ever see her in Erinn before G16 is in a flashback in G15 long before the wars.
  • Cichol
    • I agree with most of the first part of this but do have some problems, again some of this is just facts and not specifically aimed towards you.
    • Calling it a revival or death is inaccurate because we don't really know what happened. As you said, Cichol gets attacked by Jenna, gives the Milletian some power, he disappears, he appears at Falias at the end of G12, he speaks to Shakespear in G16 from the crossroad. There is nothing really saying if he really died or survived, or if he is dead, that doesn't just mean he's dead in Erinn and still conscious in the other worlds. We don't see Cichol in Erinn after the incident, and only some accounts from fomors (the sidequest in G15) and by Jenna, Aer, etc claim he died without really knowing for sure how to explain what happened.
    • A decoy Cichol would be an assumption, but is a good point.
    • Again, we don't kno what death is like for gods, that may just be what happens when they die.
    • Nuadha IS sealed.
  • For now I'm going to ignore the connection between Macha and Dark Knights and get back to you on that.
  • Macha
    • Everything else about Macha is spot on besides the Dorca Feadhain part, where did you get that?
  • Dark Knights
    • Spot on except, Fomors are NOT related to the Dark Knights, they're third party.
    • Dark Knights goals is to correct the past mistakes of humanity, not paladins specifically.
Pyro - (Talk)13:25, 24 August 2013