Mabinogi World Wiki is brought to you by Coty C., 808idiotz, our other patrons, and contributors like you!!
Want to make the wiki better? Contribute towards getting larger projects done on our Patreon!

Too much speculation and personal opinion

Fragment of a discussion from Talk:Gods

which doesn't say only specific gods can die, but that these gods have been known to die.
Actually that statement implies that ALL gods can die. We don't know this.
And no, only you said this and without basis at that.


“ is not that the IRC members' opinions don't matter; rather, it's more like they're not going to be considered because they're don't appear to be interested enough to post here, where the discussion is taking place, with the sole exception of you. I'm kind of of the same mind; I'm not a regular member of the IRC, and I don't think Pyro or Infodude are either

—Akira
Right, you said it without any basis and I've already demonstrated why Akira's arguement against opinions from elsewhere is invalid. Again, context is important.
I'd like to point out that you have also removed information from the page while it was still being discussed, before I readded anything.
At that point I'd given two replies for consideration, the latter of which was a warning as well as a large window in which for further arguements to be added. Nothing was forthcoming and nothing still was added to the debate for some time afterwards. So it wasn't on a whim and at the time it evidently wasn't being discussed.
And I'd also like to remind you:

“ And to be fair, you may have displayed why they may not be called gods yet, but you've not proven why they should stay in the category of "mortals".

—Akira
Again, I've already dealt with this and no retort was made to my reply to it. I don't need to prove that they're mortals. All I have to do is show why they don't belong on this page. This is basic logic.
@Akira; Admittedly I could have worded that better but context lends different meanings to each circumstance. For the latter it's more that we lack a PoV on the actions/whereabouts of the other Gods. It's not as if all the Gods in the game have come forwards to say "We don't care about Shakespeare". The statement to be reinstated however explicitly states that the other Gods aren't making any action and then slightly contradicts itself by saying "any known actions". If it's really to be included then it should be more like "no Gods except Morrighan have been known to take any action" rather than "only Morrighan has done anything about Shakespeare's escape; none of the other gods have taken any known actions."
There were no votes for and the only thing expressed was the disgust for the page and that this debate is still ongoing. In fact some even believe this page should be deleted altogether (a sentiment I don't entirely disagree with).

Mystickskye18:06, 7 April 2012