Mabinogi World Wiki is brought to you by Coty C., 808idiotz, our other patrons, and contributors like you!!
Want to make the wiki better? Contribute towards getting larger projects done on our Patreon!

Too much speculation and personal opinion

Fragment of a discussion from Talk:Gods

"Classified as a God through various context. ". This is why I said it's conjecture and opinion, which has no place on the wiki (apart from Nuadha, dunno why I said him, I was meant to say Corple). Find where it says he's actually a God. I'll bet that you can't because it's not actually in the game. Same goes for Lugh and while there's a single reference to Cromm as "god of destruction" it's dubious at best (the shitty trivia even makes note of this). You can argue that Elatha is a descendant of a Goddess but that doesn't matter. He's also the descendant of a human. Otherwise it's not stated what he is in-game other than "incubus" even if he's not of their bloodline. This is a another example of you guys deriving an idea from what you've seen in-game. Nowhere do they call him a god despite referencing his very clear link to one. Same goes with the Falias Gatekeeper, unless it's directly stated he's a God it's just you guys drawing the idea from his father. The distinction between tiers is just a construct made by you guys. It doesn't matter that they're different. It doesn't matter that none of them are alike, separating them into "low-tier/high-tier/lesser gods" is just an act by you guys and has no basis in the game. If you want to argue for it then show me where it's clearly stated and defined in game. "Trivia: All of it is factual. ", yeah no. Being factual doesn't make it fact nor does it make it pertinent. "Although the actual term is Deity, Lower-Tier Gods are promptly referred as Gods or Goddesses in-game. " is outright not a fact nor factual, it's someone failing at English. I see little basis for other statements within the trivia but at this point it no longer matters. Impetus now lies on you guys to show how/when/where all of this crap is said in game and why it matters.

Mystickskye02:53, 18 March 2012