Rewards?

I think it's funny how people wrote to obtain the titles this year completely differently than last year. There was a giant discussion last year to figure out exactly how it was done, and people ignored that entirely and tried to figure it out anew this year.

The Scoring Master is correct.

The Stealing Master is wrong. The actual requirements are to be in the top three on your team and return the most of your own flag. This is only give one per game, not per team. So if someone returns more flags from their own team than you do, but aren't in the top three, no one is given the title for the round. (It may possibly be top 5, however.)

And for defending master, you need to be first place on your team, and you have to kill the most. You can turn in any flag at all.

You can get all three titles with ONLY turning in your own teams flag. So just stalk your flag and kill people when they take one, then turn it back in.