Talk:Battle Short Sword

Description and Release Date

Doesn't have an English description yet. According to itemdb.xml, comes out Generation 8, Season 3. --Js16 22:28, 11 May 2009 (UTC)

If you can find its description in there, feel free to add it. ---Angevon 16:34, 12 May 2009 (UTC)

Upgrade Sequences

There were none. I added some. Other people should add more. --Jerl 03:06, 17 December 2009 (UTC)

The harden one is incorrect, it should be 40 max attack, not 43. -Fixed that. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Aku (talk • contribs) . Please always sign your comments with the button or by typing ~~~~!

dark images

Replace to follow Image Policy? -- ladywinter ~{talk page}~ 21:52, 24 April 2010 (UTC)

Done and Done. =D --DarkWyvern 15:17, 9 May 2010 (UTC)

ty! <3 -- ladywinter ~{talk page}~ 16:07, 9 May 2010 (UTC)

One such example is the contradiction in addition with the 140 and 200 Highest Max paths. If Nicca's upgrade gives more max damage than annealing 1, then why does the 140 path (which states highest max) not use it for an additional +3 max? I'm going to only list min and max damage in my corrected comparison:

140 Path: Starting Stats: 9-21 After Annealing 4: 9-26 After Annealing 4: 9-31 After Annealing 3: 9-35 After Annealing 2: 9-38 After Annealing 1: 9-40

200 Highest Max Path: Starting Stats: 9-21 After Edern Mod: 19-21 After Annealing 4: 19-26 After Annealing 3: 19-30 After Annealing 2: 19-33 After Nicca Mod: 19-38

Complete contradiction there. I'm going to try to edit the article to fix the upgrade sequences, and delete some (according to the current upgrades, though I doubt they are all correct) that are obsolete. If I should make a mistake on the page, please tell me what I did wrong on my talk page, and I will try not to make that mistake again.

If they're wrong then fix them

I shouldn't even be on my computer on the wiki right now. I have homework, and I can't start up Mabi without being noticed by my parents. Sorry, but maybe you could spend some money right now in game to check the upgrades? That is what, 6k without repairs? With a full repair, that is about 9k in game and 25 prof. Doubt you even need to repair. Not trying to sound rude, just don't have time. D:

Instead of editing the page with possible wrong edits, I'm going to post what the correct paths are using the current upgrades and their effects listed:

Type	Upgrade 1 Proficiency / Cost	Upgrade 2 Proficiency / Cost	Upgrade 3 Proficiency / Cost	Upgrade 4 Proficiency / Cost	Upgrade 5 Proficiency / Cost	Final Stats & Changes Total Proficiency / Cost
160 High Critical Max>Min Low Balance	Ferghus's Strength Modification 70 / 22,000G	Corner Grind 2 10 / 1,400G	Corner Grind 3 15 / 2,100G	Corner Grind 3 15 / 2,100G	Nicca's Strength Modification 50 / 12,000G	Attack 24~26 Critical 38% Balance 29% Durability 5 160 / 39,600G
170 Highest Min Damage Min>Max	Ferghus's Strength Modification 70 / 22,000G	Lightweight 25 / 1,700G	Lightweight 25 / 1,700G	Lightweight 25 / 1,700G	Lightweight 25 / 1,700G	Attack 40~21 Critical 23% Balance 40% Durability 5 170 / 28,800G
180 Highest Critical Max>Min Low Balance	Ferghus's Strength Modification 70 / 22,000G	Corner Grind 2 10 / 1,400G	Corner Grind 3 15 / 2,100G	Corner Grind 3 15 / 2,100G	Enhanced Tempering 70 / 12,000G	Attack 24~31 Critical 43% Balance 29% Durability 5 180 / 39,600G
180 Keeps Durability	Annealing 4 40 / 7,000G	Annealing 4 40 / 7,000G	Lightweight 25 / 1,700G	Lightweight 25 / 1,700G	Nicca's Strength Modification 50 / 12,000G	Attack 17~36 Critical 16% Balance 50% Durability 10 180 / 29,400G
180 High Max Damage Keeps Durability	Annealing 4 40 / 7,000G	Annealing 4 40 / 7,000G	Annealing 3 30 / 5,000G	Annealing 2 20 / 3,100G	Nicca's Strength Modification 50 / 12,000	Attack 9~42 Critical 14% Balance 50% Durability 10 180 / 34,100
200 Highest Max Damage Keeps Durability	Annealing 4 40 / 7,000G	Annealing 4 40 / 7,000G	Annealing 3 30 / 5,000G	Annealing 2 20 / 3,100G	Enhanced Tempering 70 / 12,000	Attack 9~47 Critical 19% Balance 50% Durability 10 200 / 34,100

I checked all the upgrades - minus the Edern Strengthening and Enhanced Tempering - and they are all correct. It seems that the special hardening would just be a stronger version of Nicca's upgrade, and Edern's upgrade isn't even used, so I think it will work. I'm going to implement this list in place of the current upgrade sequence list on the page.